Derek Carr Open to NFL Return for Super Bowl Contender
By Alex Sterling, Everythiiing.com | February 13, 2026
A Surprising U-Turn? Carr Opens Door to NFL Comeback
Nine months after announcing his retirement from the New Orleans Saints, veteran quarterback Derek Carr has thrown a curveball into the NFL landscape. In a recent appearance on his podcast, Carr revealed that he is not entirely closed off to a return to professional football, but his conditions are stringent. The 34-year-old signal-caller made it clear that any potential comeback would hinge on two crucial factors: his health and a genuine opportunity to compete for a Super Bowl title.
The Sticking Points: Health and a Championship Window
Carr, who publicly retired from the Saints in May 2025, cited lingering effects from a shoulder injury that hampered his final season as a primary reason for stepping away. However, he indicated that his physical condition is improving, fueling the possibility of a return. "Would I do it? Yes," Carr stated on his podcast, as reported by Pro Football Talk. "Would I do it for anybody? Absolutely not. I’d have to be healthy and I’d want a chance to win a Super Bowl. And obviously, that’s a tough thing to find. That’s hard to do. That’s not easy." This sentiment underscores Carr's desire to make a triumphant return, rather than simply prolonging his career. The emphasis on a "chance to win a Super Bowl" suggests that he's not looking for a sentimental farewell tour, but rather a situation where he can make a significant impact on a winning team. This aligns with the career trajectory of many veteran quarterbacks who, as they near the end of their playing days, prioritize legacy and championship contention over other factors.
Early Interest, But No Fits Yet
Carr also hinted that the interest in his services hasn't been entirely one-sided. He revealed that some NFL teams have already reached out, exploring the possibility of his return. However, he has so far declined these overtures, deeming them not the right fit for his specific criteria. "I had to say no a couple times so far," Carr admitted, suggesting that the teams that have contacted him do not currently present the championship-level opportunity he seeks.
Navigating the Saints' Contract and Trade Rights
A significant hurdle that remains to be cleared before any potential return is Carr's contractual situation with the New Orleans Saints. He was still under contract when he announced his retirement. It is currently unclear whether the Saints have granted him permission to speak with other teams or what, if any, compensation they might seek in exchange for his rights should he decide to play again. This situation could involve a trade, even though Carr is technically retired, adding a layer of complexity to any potential move.
A Calculated Gamble for a Championship
Derek Carr's journey in the NFL has been marked by periods of considerable success, particularly during his tenure with the Las Vegas Raiders, where he established himself as a prolific passer. His move to the Saints was an attempt to find a new environment and continue his pursuit of a Super Bowl. While that chapter has closed, his latest statements suggest that the fire to compete at the highest level still burns.
The quarterback landscape in the NFL is perpetually shifting, with teams constantly seeking to upgrade their rosters in pursuit of a championship. Carr's willingness to consider a return, albeit conditionally, could present an intriguing option for franchises looking for experienced leadership under center, provided they can meet his ambitious requirements. His decision will undoubtedly be closely watched by fans and analysts alike, as it could signal a significant development for both his career and any team that manages to secure his services.
What's Next for Derek Carr?
As the NFL offseason progresses, the question on many minds will be which teams might possess the Super Bowl aspirations and the necessary roster to attract a player of Derek Carr's caliber. His criteria are high, but not insurmountable for teams at the top of league standings. The coming months will likely reveal whether his desire for a championship run will translate into a return to the gridiron, or if his retirement will remain permanent.
The NFL, always a league of surprises, may just see one of its prominent quarterbacks make an unexpected comeback, but only if the stars align perfectly for a shot at the ultimate prize.
